Drew here. Twenty-nine years behind a badge, and one thing I learned early is that evidence doesn't always give you the answer when you find it. Sometimes the science isn't there yet. Sometimes the name you're looking for isn't in any database. And sometimes a clue has to sit quietly in an evidence room for half a century before somebody finally knows what to do with it.
This week, two teenage sisters take a vacation to the Florida Keys in 1973 and never make it home. Detectives had evidence, but no suspect. Fifty-three years later, that old evidence finally gave them a name.
Let's get into it.
Two Sisters Were Killed in 1973. DNA Just Gave Detectives a Name.

April 1973. Marguerite “Maggie” Jenkins, 18, and her younger sister Mary, 16, travel from New Jersey to Key West for a vacation. On May 2, they're last seen hitchhiking on Stock Island. The following day, a resident discovers both sisters in a wooded area off U.S. 1 near Key Largo. They had been badly beaten and suffered apparent gunshot wounds.
Detectives worked the case, but there was no suspect to charge and no arrest to make. Years passed, then decades. The case stayed open while the evidence stayed behind. One piece would eventually matter more than anyone could have known in 1973: a bloodstain recovered from one of the victims' clothing.
In 2018, forensic investigators developed a partial male DNA profile from that evidence and entered it into the national DNA system. No match. Five more years passed before investigators turned to forensic genetic genealogy, the same kind of work that can take an unknown DNA profile, trace family connections and slowly build a path toward a possible identity. That work led detectives to David Allen Snyder.
Investigators then did what I'd want done before putting a man's name anywhere near a 53-year-old double homicide. They collected DNA from one of Snyder's relatives and compared it with the old evidence. Florida authorities announced this month that the results confirmed Snyder as their suspect and said further investigation placed him in the Key West area around the time the sisters were killed.
There was only one problem. Snyder had died in Idaho in 2008.
MY TAKE
This is why you preserve evidence even when you've run out of leads. In 1973, that bloodstain couldn't tell detectives enough. In 2018, it could give them a profile but still no name. By 2023, the technology had changed again, and suddenly the same evidence could point investigators toward an entire family tree.
That's good detective work, but there's something frustrating about the timing. If authorities are right, the answer was sitting in that evidence for decades while the man they eventually identified went on living his life. By the time science finally caught up with the case, there would be no interrogation, no trial and no chance to ask the question every detective wants answered.
Why? For more than 50 years, the Jenkins family didn't even have a name to attach to what happened to Maggie and Mary. Now they do.
Sometimes that's as close to an arrest as an old case is ever going to get.
BAD GUYS, WORSE DECISIONS
Alright, enough of the heavy stuff. Three from this week's "what were they thinking" pile caught on camera.
They Picked the One Target Where Deputies Were Already Waiting

Palm Coast, Florida: Sheriff's deputies say a man walked into Target, grabbed a plastic storage container, filled it with 98 packs of sports trading cards worth more than $2,500 and headed for the exit. It apparently wasn't the first time he'd tried the routine. What was different this time was the deputy already standing outside investigating a completely unrelated bicycle theft.
Deputies arrested the man and the woman allegedly waiting in the getaway car before they could leave. A search of the vehicle reportedly turned up methamphetamine, fentanyl and a stolen handgun, while authorities also discovered the man had four outstanding warrants. I've seen people pick the wrong door, the wrong house and the wrong victim. Walking out with stolen merchandise while the sheriff's office is already in the parking lot deserves its own category.
The Cybertruck Was Driving Itself, He Said

Leesburg, Florida: Police arrested a 53-year-old man on a DUI charge after a witness reported seeing his Cybertruck cross into oncoming traffic and force another vehicle onto the grass. Officers said they smelled alcohol, noticed slurred speech and heard the driver acknowledge he'd been drinking.
His explanation, according to the arrest affidavit, was essentially that he wasn't driving because the Cybertruck could drive itself. Police disagreed. There's a point in most traffic stops where the explanation makes things better or makes things much worse. Blaming the car while you're the only person sitting behind the wheel usually tells me which direction we're heading.
The Speeding Ticket That Found Everything Else

Arcadia, Florida: A deputy pulls over a van allegedly doing 75 in a 60. Routine traffic stop, until he walks up to the driver's window and sees an AR-15 sitting beside a man authorities describe as a six-time convicted felon who was also driving on a suspended license.
A K9 search followed. Deputies say they found 77 grams of methamphetamine, a scale, a pipe and, because apparently this stop needed one more surprise, 11 pounds of illegally harvested saw palmetto berries. The driver reportedly told deputies the drugs weren't all his, but admitted harvesting the berries without being able to produce a permit. I've opened enough trunks and glove boxes to know a simple traffic stop can become something else very quickly, but meth, a rifle and eleven pounds of berries is a property sheet I wouldn't have predicted when the radar gun first went off.
Stay sharp out there. The people who get hurt are usually the ones who thought it couldn't happen on their street.
— Detective Drew
