Drew here.

Old cases are difficult because eventually fact and folklore start getting mixed together. Villisca has had more than a century of both, but you really do not need the ghost stories to make this one unsettling. Eight people went to sleep inside a small Iowa house on a Sunday night.

By morning, every person in that house was dead, and whoever killed them appears to have spent time there before walking away.

Eight Dead by Morning, and Nobody Heard a Thing

On June 9, 1912, Josiah and Sarah Moore came home from a church program in Villisca, Iowa, with their four children and two young sisters, Lena and Ina Stillinger, who were staying the night. They arrived home around 10 p.m., settled in, and went to bed. At some point during the night, someone took an axe belonging to Josiah and moved through the house from bedroom to bedroom. By morning, all eight people had been killed. Six of them were children.

A neighbor noticed the house was unusually quiet the next morning and eventually called Josiah's brother, Ross. He unlocked the door and found the first victims downstairs. The town marshal searched the rest of the house and found the others still in their beds. Then investigators started noticing the details that made the scene even stranger. Mirrors and glass had been covered with clothing, bedding had been pulled over the victims' faces, and the axe had been left inside. Investigators also documented a large piece of bacon beside the weapon, a plate of uneaten food and a bowl of bloody water in the kitchen.

From there, the investigation became a mess. People moved through the house before the scene had been properly protected, evidence was handled badly, and suspects came and went. The strangest may have been traveling preacher George Kelly, who had been in Villisca around the time of the murders and later confessed. He withdrew the confession, his first trial ended without a conviction, and a second jury acquitted him. Other suspects were investigated, but nobody was ever successfully prosecuted. More than a century later, the Villisca murders remain unsolved.

MY TAKE

What bothers me most is not that the killer got away. Plenty of people got away with murder in 1912. Investigators did not have DNA, modern fingerprint databases, surveillance cameras or any of the tools we would depend on today.

What bothers me is how comfortable this person seems to have been inside the house. If the scene was documented correctly, somebody killed eight people across several rooms, covered mirrors and glass, covered the victims' faces, left the weapon behind and apparently spent enough time there to alter the scene before leaving.

That is not what I picture when I think of somebody panicking and running for the door. It makes me wonder what the killer knew. Did they know the family? Did they know nobody would visit before morning? Did they know the rhythm of the neighborhood well enough to feel safe staying inside?

People have spent 114 years trying to put a name to whoever walked through that house. I would start with something simpler. Why did they feel so comfortable staying?

BAD GUYS, WORSE DECISIONS

Alright, enough of the heavy stuff. Three from this week's "what were they thinking" pile caught on camera.

Three Boats. Twelve Days. Three Arrests.

1205 Craftsman Way, Everett, Washington: Everett police say the same man was arrested three times in twelve days in connection with three allegedly stolen boats. Police first encountered him aboard a stolen vessel at the Port of Everett Marina, then authorities say they found him four days later with another stolen boat while he was pulling a crab pot from the water. Days later, police say he was staying aboard a third stolen vessel. He was arrested after each incident and released after each arrest.

I've dealt with repeat offenders before, but three boats in twelve days suggests a level of specialization I don't normally see. After the second arrest, I might have considered taking a few days away from the marina.

Apparently the sea kept calling.

Minnesota's Largest Candy Store Became "Most Wanted"

20430 Johnson Memorial Drive, Jordan, Minnesota: The owner of Minnesota's Largest Candy Store has been charged with allegedly selling liquor-filled candy without the required license. State investigators say undercover agents bought products including a Jack Daniel's chocolate bar and brandy-filled cherries. Owner Robert Wagner says he believed the products were legal to sell and disputes the state's interpretation.

Then he changed the giant sign outside the store. For a while, Minnesota's Largest Candy Store became Minnesota's Most Wanted Candy Store.

I've seen plenty of people respond to criminal charges with carefully worded statements written by attorneys. Turning the whole thing into roadside advertising is considerably more entertaining. Whatever happens in court, I have to give the man credit for not wasting a marketing opportunity.

Two People Picked the Same Morning to Test White House Security

16th Street and H Street NW, Washington, D.C.: Just before 10 a.m. Monday, a vehicle drove onto the sidewalk beside Lafayette Park near the White House. The Secret Service says the driver became combative and was arrested. Around the same time, a second person separately jumped a security barricade near the northwest corner of the park and was also taken into custody. Authorities have not said the two incidents were connected.

One incident outside the White House creates enough work for everybody. Having another person apparently see a growing collection of Secret Service officers, police and National Guard personnel and decide that this was also a good time to jump a barricade is difficult to understand.

There are calls where dispatch gives you the facts and you immediately ask them to repeat the whole thing. I imagine this was one of those mornings.

Stay sharp out there. The people who get hurt are usually the ones who thought it couldn't happen on their street.

— Detective Drew