Drew here. Twenty-nine years behind a badge, and the cases that still bother me aren't always the bl**diest ones. They're the ones where one detail doesn't fit, then another, and before long the official story starts asking you to ignore more than it explains.
This week takes us to West Virginia on Christmas Eve, 1945. A house burns to the ground, five children are presumed dead, but their parents never find the proof they expect to find. Then comes a cut phone line, a missing ladder, trucks that suddenly won't start, and witnesses claiming they saw the children after the fire.
Pour something. Let's get into it.
Five Kids Vanished in a Fire, and No Bones Were Ever Found

Christmas Eve, 1945. George and Jennie Sodder are asleep in their West Virginia home when the phone rings after midnight. Jennie answers to a woman she doesn't know asking for a name she's never heard of. She hangs up. Not long after, she wakes again after hearing something hit the roof and roll across it. Around 1:30 a.m., she smells smoke.
The house is on fire. George and Jennie get outside with four of their children, but five are still believed to be upstairs. George tries to go back in, but the staircase is already burning, so he runs for the ladder normally kept beside the house. It's gone. He tries starting one of his work trucks to reach the upstairs windows. It won't start. Neither will the second. Then they discover the phone is dead.
By morning, the house is gone and the five children are presumed dead. That should have been the end of it. It wasn't.
The family couldn't find identifiable remains that convinced them five children had died inside. Then the missing ladder turned up down an embankment away from the house. A telephone repairman later said the phone line hadn't burned through.
It had been cut.
MY TAKE
That's the moment I'd stop treating this as an ordinary house fire.
A missing ladder can be explained. A dead truck can be bad luck. Even the lack of obvious remains can happen after a severe fire. But when the phone line is cut, the ladder needed to reach the children has been moved, two vehicles suddenly won't start, and nobody can give the parents physical proof their children died inside, the clues start pointing in the same direction.
I'd want to know whether those children were ever upstairs when the fire took hold.
George had another reason to be suspicious. Months earlier, an insurance salesman reportedly became angry after George refused to buy a policy and warned that his house would someday “go up in smoke.” George had also openly criticized Mussolini and believed those views had made him enemies within the local Italian community.
None of that proves kidnapping. But it's exactly the kind of thing you investigate before deciding five children simply vanished into a fire.
The years afterward only made the family more certain. Witnesses claimed they had seen children resembling the Sodders after the blaze, and years later the family received a photograph of a young man they believed might be their missing son Louis. No lead ever produced an answer.
George and Jennie put up a roadside billboard carrying the faces of their five children and kept searching for decades. George died believing they had survived. Jennie died in 1989 still waiting to find out what happened.
That's what stays with me. The possibility that five children may have disappeared before anyone realized there was a crime to investigate.
BAD GUYS, WORSE DECISIONS
Alright, enough of the heavy stuff. Three from this week's "what were they thinking" pile caught on camera.

Seminole, Florida: Police say three intoxicated men showed up outside a Waffle House around 4:30 in the morning, some reportedly wearing little more than underwear, and started pounding on the restaurant's windows. Then, for reasons the arrest report does not explain, they began throwing beef sticks at the building.
By the time officers arrived, the three had apparently moved on from the attack and were sitting on a bench outside a laundromat next door. All three were arrested for disorderly conduct and later released on $150 bond.
I've responded to enough late-night calls to know that alcohol can turn a bad idea into a criminal charge pretty quickly. But standing outside a Waffle House at 4:30 in the morning, half-dressed and using beef jerky as ammunition is a sequence of decisions I'd need explained one at a time.
Police records apparently don't say what brand of beef stick was used. Some evidence, I suppose, stays classified.
Crooked Jess Lived Up to the Name

St. Petersburg, Florida: Undercover deputies were running a buy-and-bust operation and handed $60 to a woman known on the street as “Crooked Jess.” Her job was simple: take the money, buy crack cocaine and return with the product. Instead, she walked toward a house, disappeared around the back and never came back.
The deputies reportedly waited about an hour before accepting what had happened: the woman they had trusted with police money had simply taken it. She was arrested months later.
I've worked with enough informants to know street names don't always mean much, but when the person you're handing cash to is called “Crooked Jess,” maybe believe the advertising.
She Torched the Church the Day Before the Wedding

Kaysville, Utah: A bride-to-be was inside a church with her fiancé and family preparing for their wedding the following day when the fire alarm went off. A fire had started beneath a stack of chairs, and although family members managed to put it out, the damage reportedly climbed above $100,000.
Investigators then began working backward. Police say surveillance footage from earlier that day showed the bride at a hardware store taking cigarette lighters without paying for them, and they also discovered she allegedly hadn't obtained the marriage license she claimed to have. She was later arrested on allegations including aggravated arson.
I've worked enough arsons to know there's usually something underneath the fire: money, revenge, anger, an attempt to destroy evidence. I can't tell you what the motive was here, but if you're accused of setting fire to the church where you're supposed to get married the next morning, the seating chart probably isn't your biggest problem anymore.
Stay sharp out there. The people who get hurt are usually the ones who thought it couldn't happen on their street.
— Detective Drew

