Andrew here. I've always found that the cases that stick with you aren't necessarily the ones with the least evidence. Sometimes they're the opposite. You've got witnesses, suspects, physical evidence and a pretty good idea of what may have happened, but somehow nobody ever gets put in front of a jury.
Cabin 28 is one of those cases. A mother and two teenage boys were found killed inside a small California cabin. Three younger boys had slept only a room away and survived. A 12-year-old girl was missing. Then, three years later, part of the answer turned up more than 60 miles away.
And somehow, that only made the case stranger.
She Appeared on The People's Court. Then She Disappeared.

April 12, 1981. Fourteen-year-old Sheila Sharp comes home after spending the night at a neighbor's house in Keddie, a tiny former railroad town in Northern California. She opens Cabin 28 and finds her mother, Sue Sharp, her 15-year-old brother John, and John's 17-year-old friend Dana Wingate dead in the living room. They had been bound and violently attacked during the night.
Then somebody checks the bedroom. Three younger boys who had also been inside the cabin that night are still there, alive. But Sue's 12-year-old daughter Tina isn't. Police search the area, the FBI becomes involved, and Tina simply seems to have disappeared from the cabin while three other children were left behind. Nearly three years later, her remains were discovered near Feather Falls, more than 60 miles from Keddie.
Investigators had people they were interested in, particularly Martin “Marty” Smartt, who lived nearby, and his friend John Boubede, but neither man was charged. Then decades later the old case started producing evidence again. In 2016, investigators recovered a hammer from a pond near Keddie that matched the description of one Smartt had reportedly said was missing. A letter Smartt wrote to his wife weeks after the murders included a disturbing reference to having “bought” her love with four people's lives, and investigators later said DNA found on medical tape from the original crime scene matched a known living person of interest. Still, no arrest followed.
That's what makes Cabin 28 difficult to put down. This isn't a case where forty years later there's nothing left to work with. Investigators have had suspects. They've had a possible weapon. They've had DNA. They've had an extraordinary letter. And yet the official answer to who killed Sue, John, Dana and Tina is still the same today.
MY TAKE
I keep going back to the three boys.
Think about the scene for a second. Whoever did this spends enough time inside that little cabin to overpower and kill three people. Tina somehow leaves the cabin with them or is taken from it. And yet three children sleeping only a room away survive.
Why? Maybe they genuinely slept through more than you'd think possible. Maybe whoever was inside deliberately left them alone. Maybe the killer believed they hadn't seen anything. There are accounts from the investigation suggesting at least one of the boys may have remembered pieces of that night, but decades of contradictory statements and investigative mistakes make it difficult to know exactly what can be trusted.
And then there's Tina. Taking her away creates risk. You have to get her out of the cabin, move her, and eventually leave her more than 60 miles away. Somebody made that choice while leaving everyone else at the scene.
That's the part I'd want explained before almost anything else. Not just who entered Cabin 28 that night. Why did three children get to wake up the next morning, while Tina never came home?
BAD GUYS, WORSE DECISIONS
Alright, enough of the heavy stuff. Three from this week's "what were they thinking" pile caught on camera.
He Jumped Through the Window. His ID Stayed Behind.

Oklahoma County, Oklahoma: Sheriff's deputies recently released bodycam footage from a burglary call at a vacant house. A deputy walks inside and allegedly finds a man removing copper wiring from a dishwasher. He orders him to get on his knees, the man looks like he's about to comply, then changes plans rather dramatically and dives headfirst through a closed glass window.
For a moment, it works. He gets away from the house before the deputy can catch him. Unfortunately, police say he left his belongings behind, including his identification, and was arrested soon afterward. The sheriff's office joked that he'd missed his calling as a Hollywood stuntman. I'd agree, although most stuntmen probably remember to take their wallet with them.
The Mystery of Who Kept Peeing Around Campus

St. Paul, Minnesota: Macalester College had an unusual problem developing inside its science building. Urine had reportedly been found in trash cans, water bottles and even other professors' decorations. Then a student left her backpack unattended near biology professor Paul Fischer's office for roughly six minutes and returned to find it wet with urine, with the contents allegedly suffering more than $2,000 in damage.
Police say Fischer later acknowledged that he'd developed a habit of urinating into a cup and dumping it into trash cans or laboratory sinks, although he reportedly said the student's backpack may have been splashed accidentally. The former professor, who taught at Macalester for more than 25 years, now faces a first-degree property-damage charge and has not been convicted.
I've worked cases where you spend months trying to identify the person behind a pattern of incidents. I'm not sure “serial campus urination” is one I'd expect to see written across the evidence board.
The Police Chief Who Allegedly Won His Own Raffle

Quitman, Georgia: The Georgia Bureau of Investigation says the Quitman Police Department received a donated handgun earlier this year that was supposed to be raffled off during a regional traffic-enforcement meeting. Investigators allege Police Chief Lawrence McGee had another idea: instead of putting the gun into the raffle, he kept it for himself.
A grand jury later indicted McGee, and the GBI arrested him this week on charges of felony theft by taking and violation of oath of office. The case has been turned over to prosecutors, and the charges remain allegations.
I've seen people try to rig contests before. Usually the person accused of doing it isn't also the police chief.
If investigators have this right, that's less “winning the raffle” and more “deciding nobody else needed a ticket.
Stay sharp out there. The people who get hurt are usually the ones who thought it couldn't happen on their street.
— Detective Drew
