Drew here. Twenty-nine years behind a badge, and locking up the right suspect usually makes something change. The calls stop. The threats stop. The victim finally sleeps. So when the crime keeps happening after your guy is sitting behind bars, you've got a problem.
That's what happened in Circleville, Ohio. Someone spent years mailing letters that knew far too much about people's private lives, and when investigators finally thought they'd found the writer, the letters kept coming.
Pour something. Let's get into it.
The Letters Kept Coming After the Suspect Was Locked Away

It started in the late 1970s with handwritten letters arriving around Circleville, a small Ohio town. The writer seemed especially interested in school bus driver Mary Gillispie, accusing her of having an affair with married school superintendent Gordon Massie. But these weren't harmless gossip notes. The writer claimed to be watching Mary's house, knew where her children went to school and eventually threatened her family. Before long, letters were showing up at businesses, government offices and other homes around town.
Then Mary's husband, Ron, started receiving them too. In August 1977, he reportedly received a mysterious phone call, grabbed a gun and drove off saying he was going to confront whoever was behind the harassment. His truck later crashed into a tree and killed him. A revolver found beneath his body had been fired once. The coroner ruled the death an accident, but the circumstances gave Circleville one more question nobody could answer.
The letters continued for years. Then, in February 1983, Mary was driving her empty school bus when she spotted an obscene sign about her 13-year-old daughter along the route. She stopped to remove it and discovered twine leading to a wooden box. Inside was a loaded .25-caliber handgun rigged as a booby trap.
Investigators restored the gun's partially erased serial number and traced it back to Mary's brother-in-law, Paul Freshour. Freshour admitted the gun had belonged to him but said it had been stolen weeks earlier. Nobody had seen him placing the device, no fingerprints tied him to the trap and witnesses gave him an alibi for much of that day, but two handwriting examiners said his writing could match the anonymous letters. Freshour was convicted of attempted murder and sent to prison. He was never charged with writing the Circleville letters.
Police thought it was over. It wasn't.
Letters kept arriving while Freshour was incarcerated. They reportedly continued even after prison officials placed him in isolation and restricted his access to writing materials, and at one point Freshour himself received one. The campaign finally faded around the same period he was released in the 1990s.
MY TAKE
The gun is the piece I'd have trouble walking away from. It belonged to Freshour, and handwriting evidence pointed toward him. But good investigations don't stop where the evidence becomes inconvenient.
If Freshour was doing it from prison, somebody had to be helping him. If he wasn't, then either there was another writer all along or somebody saw his conviction as perfect cover and kept the campaign going.
Even experts looking at the case decades later don't agree. Former FBI profiler Mary Ellen O'Toole said she had doubts Freshour was the writer, while forensic document examiner Beverley East studied dozens of letters and said she was convinced he was.
If I were reopening it, I'd start with three questions: who knew enough about Mary to write those first letters, who could have gotten access to Freshour's gun, and who still had a reason to keep writing once he was safely behind bars.
Because that's the detail that bothers me. They caught their suspect. The crime didn't stop.
BAD GUYS, WORSE DECISIONS
Alright, enough of the heavy stuff. Three from this week's "what were they thinking" pile caught on camera.
He Cut Through the Crime Scene Tape. With a Knife.

Aliquippa, Pennsylvania: Police were working an active shooting scene Tuesday evening when a 43-year-old man approached the perimeter and was told not to cross it. According to police, he responded by pulling out a knife, cutting through the crime scene tape and trying to walk into the scene anyway.
He didn't get far. Officers immediately arrested him on charges including obstruction and disorderly conduct. Crime scene tape isn't decorative, and it definitely isn't a challenge. If you have to pull out a knife to get past the thing police just told you not to cross, I'd argue the warning was fairly clear.
Filmed His Own Crime and Handed Cops the Case

Islamorada, Florida: Deputies say three intoxicated men spent roughly four hours creating what the sheriff's office called an ongoing “ruckus” at a Florida Keys resort. Witnesses reported the trio fighting with each other, banging on guests' doors, threatening people who asked them to quiet down and, eventually, activating the resort's fire alarm despite there being no fire.
Deputies arrived around 6:30 in the morning and arrested all three on disorderly conduct and false fire-alarm charges. I've answered enough overnight disturbance calls to know they rarely improve with time. If the night starts with three grown men fighting each other and ends with an entire resort standing outside because somebody pulled the fire alarm, morning checkout is probably the least of your problems.
Police Found Eight iPhones Under the Taxi Driver's Seat

Miami Beach, Florida: Police say a taxi driver and an alleged accomplice had a system for targeting intoxicated people leaving South Beach clubs. Investigators allege victims' phones were stolen and their faces or other biometric information were then used to unlock the devices and move money from their accounts.
Detectives followed the trail through surveillance footage, cellphone records and city cameras before arresting the driver Tuesday. When officers searched his cab, police say they found a plastic bag containing eight iPhones underneath the driver's seat. The alleged accomplice remained wanted when the arrest was announced.
There's planning a crime, and then there's storing eight pieces of potential evidence beneath the seat of the vehicle police say you're using to commit it. Detectives appreciate organization too.
Stay sharp out there. Catching a suspect can close a case, but it doesn't necessarily answer it. Sometimes the evidence keeps talking long after everybody else has decided they're finished listening.
— Detective Drew

