Drew here. Twenty-nine years behind a badge, and one thing I learned pretty early is that when people leave voluntarily, they usually take the things they need to keep living. Their car, their purse, their money, their keys. Maybe not everything, but something usually tells you they planned on leaving.

This week takes us to Springfield, Missouri, where three women disappeared from the same house in 1992. Their cars stayed outside, their money and keys stayed inside, the family dog was still there, and police found no apparent signs of a struggle. Thirty-four years later, we still don't know how three people left that house without anybody seeing where they went.

Let's get into it.

The Last Night Anyone Saw Sherrill, Suzie and Stacy

June 6, 1992. Suzie Streeter, 19, and her friend Stacy McCall, 18, had just graduated high school and spent the evening going between graduation parties around Springfield. Eventually they decided to stay at Suzie's house, where her mother, 47-year-old Sherrill Levitt, was already home. The FBI believes Suzie and Stacy returned sometime around 2:15 that morning. By roughly 7:30 a.m., all three women had disappeared.

When people came to the house later that morning, the front door was open, but almost everything you would expect three people to take with them was still there. Their cars hadn't moved. Money, clothing, keys and other personal belongings were inside, and the family dog had been left behind. Police found no apparent signs of a struggle. Friends, neighbors and investigators searched around Springfield and surrounding areas, but nothing led them to Sherrill, Suzie or Stacy.

That's where this gets strange for me. One person leaving unexpectedly without their wallet or car happens. Maybe they stepped outside with somebody, maybe they planned on coming straight back, maybe there is an explanation you haven't found yet. But now I've got three women leaving the same house, at roughly the same time, without their vehicles or the basic things they would normally take with them. That gets harder to explain away.

Police have followed thousands of leads over the years. The FBI became involved, along with the Missouri State Highway Patrol and other agencies, but authorities still say they have no confirmed answer for why the women disappeared or where they went. Springfield police continue to consider the investigation active.

MY TAKE

Look, I understand why people want one weird clue that solves the whole thing. That's how these cases get talked about years later. Somebody finds one odd detail and suddenly everything has to revolve around it. Unfortunately, investigations usually aren't that convenient. What bothers me here is much simpler: you've got to get three people out of that house.

If I'm working this, I want to know who could make all three women leave without creating an obvious fight inside. Maybe somebody had a weapon. Maybe there was more than one person. Maybe whoever showed up was somebody they knew, which would explain why nobody immediately felt the need to fight or run. Suzie and Stacy also ended up at that house after graduation parties, so I'd want to know who knew where they were going and whether all three women were supposed to be there in the first place.

That's what sticks with me. Cars outside, belongings inside, dog still home, and three people gone. Thirty-four years later, we still don't know what made them walk out that door or whether they ever got the chance to walk back in.

BAD GUYS, WORSE DECISIONS

Alright, enough of the heavy stuff. Three from this week's "what were they thinking" pile caught on camera.

He Tried to Help Police Solve His Own Theft

Warrington Township, Pennsylvania: Police say 31-year-old Charles McKnight stole a student's Segway scooter from outside John Barclay Elementary School on September 10. Surveillance footage caught the theft, police posted his photograph asking for help identifying him, and tips started coming in. Then investigators received an anonymous tip claiming juveniles connected to the theft had been around the school later that night. According to police, the person who submitted that tip was McKnight himself. Officers recovered the scooter, and police say he later admitted taking it.

I've interviewed enough people who tried to point us toward somebody else, so that part isn't new. What is unusual is voluntarily inserting yourself into the investigation of your own alleged crime. If you're trying to get police looking in another direction, submitting the tip yourself probably wasn't the direction I would've gone.

The Disguise Became the Giveaway

Tulsa, Oklahoma: Police say a 28-year-old woman was caught at Scheels earlier this week with hundreds of dollars in merchandise hidden inside her bag. Store employees told officers they recognized Alexandra Byrd from previous suspected thefts, including incidents where she allegedly wore the same wig. Officers searched the bag and, according to police, found that wig inside. They say Byrd admitted to multiple thefts and was booked on organized retail crime and larceny allegations.

I've seen people use wigs, hats, glasses, different clothes, whatever they think will stop somebody from recognizing them. That's fine in theory. But if you use the same disguise enough times that employees recognize the wig, the disguise has now become part of your description. At that point we're kind of working backwards.

He Took a 65-Inch TV and Walked Into the Woods

Clarion Township, Pennsylvania: State police say surveillance video captured a man entering an apartment through a rear window and leaving about 17 minutes later carrying a 65-inch television on his back toward nearby woods. A trooper later showed the footage to 39-year-old David Kightlinger. According to the criminal complaint, when asked about the person entering through the window, he allegedly said, “That's how I always get into the apartment.” When shown the television footage, police say he replied, “Just my TV, yeah.” He now faces burglary, criminal trespass and theft charges.

Here's the thing about taking a 65-inch television: getting it out of the house is only the beginning of your problem. Now you have to disappear while carrying something roughly the size of a small wall. Walking into the woods with it on your back would not have been very high on my list.

Stay sharp out there. The people who get hurt are usually the ones who thought it couldn't happen on their street.

— Detective Drew